Ready to get help? Our helpline is available 24/7
Who Answers?
Call us: +1(214) 935-2287
  • Home
  • Rehab Facilities
  • Treatment Programs​
    • Alcoholism Treatment
      • Inpatient Alcohol Rehab
      • Outpatient Alcohol Rehab
    • Drug Recovery
    • Drug Rehab
      • Inpatient Drug Rehab
      • Outpatient Drug Rehab
    • Dual Diagnosis
      • Anxiety and Co-Occurring Substance Abuse
    • Medical Detox
    • Meth Addiction Recovery
    • Prescription Drug Recovery
    • Relapse Prevention
    • SMART Recovery
    • Withdrawal Management
  • Blog
  • Contacts
Ready to get help? Our helpline is available 24/7
Who Answers?
Call us: +1(214) 453-5663
  • Home
  • Rehab Facilities
  • Treatment Programs​
    • Alcoholism Treatment
      • Inpatient Alcohol Rehab
      • Outpatient Alcohol Rehab
    • Drug Recovery
    • Drug Rehab
      • Inpatient Drug Rehab
      • Outpatient Drug Rehab
    • Dual Diagnosis
      • Anxiety and Co-Occurring Substance Abuse
    • Medical Detox
    • Meth Addiction Recovery
    • Prescription Drug Recovery
    • Relapse Prevention
    • SMART Recovery
    • Withdrawal Management
  • Blog
  • Contacts

Is Abstinence The Only Way?

  • Home
  • Rehabilitation
  • Is Abstinence The Only Way?

In addiction treatment circles, abstinence is used to describe the ongoing act of avoiding or not partaking in specific behaviors or substances. Thus, if someone has not consumed drugs or alcohol for a period of time, they could be described as abstinent or abstaining.

Abstinence can also be used to describe treatment approaches or goals i.e. “Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous endorse abstinence-only treatment models.”

What Does Abstinence from Substances Involve?

Abstinence, at its most simple, is refraining from one’s substance of choice. Of course, in practice, this can be extremely difficult. A substance use disorder (SUD) will cause affected individuals to experience extremely strong cravings that are difficult to resist. To help recovering individuals with this, classic 12-Step programs like AA and NA will harness the power of groups.

Participation in regular thrice-weekly group meetings that follow AA and NA models has been demonstrated to greatly improve the chances of achieving long-term abstinence. Even participating just once a week has been shown to have some benefits.

Additionally, recovering individuals could go with psychotherapy and supplemental therapies like meditation and exercise. Psychotherapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy, in particular, is particularly effective at addressing cravings as well as symptoms of common co-occurring mental health conditions.

Are Abstinence-Only Goals Realistic?

Abstinence is held by many laypersons and some mental health clinicians to be the ideal goal for individuals recovering from SUD. However, reaching this goal within a short period (less than a year) is widely known to be exceedingly difficult for individuals with moderate to severe SUD.

This could be further complicated if the individual has a dual diagnosis (one or more co-occurring mental health conditions in addition to SUD) or has serious financial constraints that make a sustainable recovery more difficult.

However, abstinence-only programs continue to be the most widespread throughout the United States. Most of these follow the model endorsed by AA and NA or have some kind of religious connection to them. These programs do have their share of self-reported successes. However, a growing number of mental health clinicians consider the “all-or-nothing” approach endorsed by these groups to be outdated or mostly unworkable.

Criticisms of Abstinence-only Treatment Models

Common criticisms of abstinence-only treatment and rehabilitation include the following:

1.) May Be Outdated

Alcoholics Anonymous’s treatment model was developed before developments that led to the current understanding of the human brain and behavioral science.

For instance, the AA founders believed that so-called “alcoholics” or people with alcohol use disorder were born with their condition. They also did not yet know that repeated exposure to certain addictive substances like alcohol changes the brain works, presenting an extraordinarily complex barrier to a full recovery.

2.) Tends to Have a Specific Moral Approach

While not universal to all abstinence-only programs, the dominant rehabilitation model endorsed by AA and NA explicitly includes a spiritual aspect that is heavily Judeo-Christian. In the right circumstances, this spirituality can serve to further strengthen one’s commitment to recovery.

While this spiritual approach is a positive for many Americans, it can be isolating for a few others, making it less useful for them as a recovery framework. This focus on morality and spirituality is also often considered to be in opposition to “evidence-based treatment” models.

3.) Potentially Dangerous

Abstinence-only treatments can be dangerous for people with severe SUD. Withdrawing from some substances like alcohol or opioids can have extremely uncomfortable withdrawal symptoms, usually requiring drug substitution therapy or dosage tapering to safely stabilize the patient.

Many supporters of abstinence-only programs oppose these types of therapeutic interventions, particularly when it needs to be long-term, as is often the case with severe opioid use disorders.

4.) Early Recovery is Extremely Difficult

Even when less dangerous addictive substances are concerned, abstinence-only approaches generally make withdrawals and early recovery extremely challenging. Without gradually tapering the dosages or substituting drugs, recovering individuals may find it close to impossible to avoid relapses. This tends to reduce the effectiveness of these types of treatment models for people with severe SUD.

Find The SUD Treatment You Need Today

Abstinence-only treatments are highly accessible and work remarkably well for recovering individuals with mild to moderate SUD. However, it’s worth noting that they are no longer the only options available out there. Alternatives like SMART Recovery that lean heavily into evidence-based treatments are also well worth exploring.

If you’re in the Dallas-Fort Worth area, Dallas Drug Treatment Centers gives you access to programs that meet your unique recovery needs. Call +1(214) 935-2287 to discuss your options.

Resources:

  1. Subbaraman, M. S., & Witbrodt, J. (2014). Differences between abstinent and non-abstinent individuals in recovery from alcohol use disorders. Addictive behaviors, 39(12), 1730-1735.
  2. Krentzman, A. R., Robinson, E. A., Moore, B. C., Kelly, J. F., Laudet, A. B., White, W. L., … & Strobbe, S. (2011). How alcoholics anonymous (AA) and narcotics anonymous (NA) work: Cross-disciplinary perspectives. Alcoholism treatment quarterly, 29(1), 75-84.
  3. Fernandez, D. P., Kuss, D. J., & Griffiths, M. D. (2020). Short-term abstinence effects across potential behavioral addictions: A systematic review. Clinical psychology review, 76, 101828.
  4. Gottheil, E. (1976). Advantages and disadvantages of the abstinence goal in alcoholism. The American journal of drug and alcohol abuse, 3(1), 13-23.
Share

Related Posts

What is Motivational Interviewing?

December 7, 2021

Motivational interviewing is the concept of regularly rewarding desirable behavior to reinforce and encourage it. It is one of the oldest motivational techniques and is now

Is Biofeedback Therapy for You?

December 2, 2021

If you’ve been going through options for mental health treatment and rehab, you might find some clinicians and programs advertising biofeedback therapy as one of the

Why Is It So Hard to Quit Nicotine?

November 18, 2021

Though it might seem odd to discuss tobacco in the same vein as cocaine or heroin, tobacco is, a dangerous and addictive substance. Of course, when

Does Person-Centered Therapy Work for SUD Recovery?

November 4, 2021

While cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is the most widely used psychotherapy approach in substance use disorder (SUD) treatment, there are alternatives a therapist may prefer to use

What Does Evidence-based Treatment Mean?

October 21, 2021

Evidence-based treatment (EBT) has long been the dominant approach in most areas of healthcare. However, it did not gain as much traction in drug and alcohol

Dallas drug treatment logo

We provide a healthy environment uniquely suited to support your growth and healing.

  • +1(214) 935-2287
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com offers a free advisory service to help you or your loved ones who are struggling with addiction and may receive compensation from our Featured or Sponsored listings.

DISCLAIMER: dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is a third-party information source for consumers who are dealing with addiction or seeking information on addiction treatment. dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is not a treatment facility center. dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is a company that connects consumers with addiction treatment centers. All content and information included within dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com are intended solely for informational and marketing purposes and are not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. You should always seek medical advice from a licensed caregiver if you are experiencing any condition which may require medical treatment, and in the event of an emergency, please dial 911 immediately. Any advertiser relationships with dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com are clearly marked as “Sponsor” or “Ad”. Reliance on any content or information set forth within dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is solely at your own risk. See Terms and Conditions for further details.

NA/AA DISCLAIMER: dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is not affiliated with Narcotics Anonymous or Alcoholics Anonymous. The information on dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is provided for informational purposes only. If there are any discrepancies of times, dates, or locations of meetings, please contact us so we can update the information as we strive to keep the information as current as possible.

*Not all insurance policies are the same. Insurance coverage varies based on individual policies. The logos depicted on this page are the registered trademarks of their respective owners. dallasdrugtreatmentcenters.com is not affiliated with or sponsored by these trademark owners.





COPYRIGHT © 2021 DALLAS DRUG TREATMENT CENTERS. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Privacy PolicyTerms and Conditions